Rick Poynor | Essays

On My Shelf: Continuum’s 33 1/3 Series

No. 29, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (by Neutral Milk Hotel), Continuum, 2005

In the field of popular culture, there are two superb, long-running series of critical monographs. These projects, intellectually ambitious yet accessible and popular, should be inspirational case studies for any publisher, writer or writing student that aspires to produce equally engaging writing about design for a broad audience. One series is the BFI Film Classics, which devotes an entire volume to each film — I might return to these books another time. The other venture is Continuum’s 33 1/3 series. Here, too, each volume concentrates on a single work, in this case an album of enduring impact and artistic value.

The 33 1/3 books are a perfect example of how design can help focus an editorial idea and make it irresistible. The books are enticingly small, but their width in relation to their height makes them feel considered and substantial. The series identity is powerfully projected by the upended 33 1/3 logo, defined by a heavy drop shadow, which is always the dominant typographic element. A miniature reproduction of the original album cover is the only pictorial device; it’s celebratory, serious, archival and a little bit fetishistic all at the same time — exacty right for the audience. The album’s colors generate the areas of flat color used for the cover box, back cover and spine. Even the black border, like a frame around an illustration of the actual cover, adds a note of distinction and gravitas, enshrining both title and image.

No. 2, Forever Changes (by Love), Continuum, 2003

The first volume, devoted to Dusty Springfield’s Dusty in Memphis, appeared in 2003. Since then another 82 of the numbered titles have been published. The books I have read so far include Forever Changes (Love), Kick Out the Jams (MC5), Low (David Bowie), Unknown Pleasures (Joy Division), OK Computer (Radiohead) and In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (Neutral Milk Hotel), the series’ bestselling title. I have American poet Tony Tost’s recent volume about American Recordings, Johnny Cash’s extraordinary 1994 comeback, waiting in my in-pile. A few days ago, I finished 20 Jazz Funk Greats, which deals with the third album (1979) by Throbbing Gristle, originators of the “industrial” music genre and, in their time, one of the UK’s most alarming and controversial bands.

In some of the finest writing I have seen in the series, Drew Daniel, a member of the electronic group Matmos and a teacher in the English department at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, undertakes a dizzyingly attentive and eloquent critical reading of TG’s ironically titled album. Daniel’s imaginative ability to penetrate from afar the climate and culture of dour, politically reactionary 1970s Britain, which he didn’t experience, is impressive, and he effectively anchors his reasons for undertaking the book in his teenage attraction, living in Kentucky, to the morbid and extreme. His closely argued chapter on the band’s sly, saccharine, “easy-listening” cover artwork — the grassy cliff edge where they pose in their suspiciously ordinary leisurewear is a notorious suicide spot — warrants immediate reprint in a Looking Closer-like volume. At a time when graphic design writing lacks critical energy and commitment, a musician and English professor provides an object lesson in delving deeper and thinking harder about design as communication.

No. 54, 20 Jazz Funk Greats (by Throbbing Gristle), Continuum, 2008 

I like the series so much that a few years ago I approached 33 1/3’s editor, David Barker, with a proposal. I wanted to write about Brian Eno’s second album, Taking Tiger Mountain (By Strategy) (1974), a concept inspired by postcards of a Chinese revolutionary opera of the same name. In 2003, Doug Hilsinger and Caroleen Beatty re-created Eno’s entire album as a homage. My first book was a collaboration with the artist Russell Mills about Eno, and I thought there was more to say. My timing was off, though. It turned out there was already a project in Continuum’s pipeline focusing on the more obvious Eno classic, Another Green World (1975).

I’m hardly impartial, but for me that book didn’t come off. The American writer felt too distant from her British subject and there were no great revelations for long-term fans. The best 33 1/3 titles, like Drew Daniel’s, have an urgent personal mission, even obsession, and they tunnel deep down into an album’s defining moment and milieu: dark sixties Los Angeles in Forever Changes, isolated seventies Berlin in Low, creative nineties Athens, Georgia in In the Aeroplane over the Sea. (“There are no great records without great sleeves,” writes the author, Kim Cooper, “and Aeroplane’s is a stunner.”) Usually around 30,000 words, these detailed studies are hugely challenging to research and write. Continuum has let it be known that a batch of previously announced titles has been canceled after initial high hopes: the authors just couldn’t deliver. Even so, the publisher won’t be signing up any more titles for some time. I hope this isn’t an indication they are starting to slow up. The well of exceptional popular music albums is so deep that the series could run for decades, and the listener’s attachment to a favorite album is often fierce.

No. 26, Low (by David Bowie), Continuum, 2005

Posted in: Graphic Design, Media, Music , Theory + Criticism

Comments [7]

Wow! I'm going to go into enthusiasm overdrive and say you have an amazing ability to ferret out some of the best off-center cultural stuff around. I had a look at Continuum's website and I think I want to take a week off and read most of these. And, of course, they'll make great presents. Any more from the series that you would recommend? Anyone else out there who has also read any of these? They should be better known. Thanks, Rick.
Adam Harrison Levy

Adam, I enjoyed "Celine Dion's Lets Talk About Love" from the 33 1/3 series. The essay was basically this long bit of wrangling over the difference between art and kitsch. In the end, the author has this measured appreciation of Dion's work. (Which I don't share; I grew out of liking Dion sometime in my teens, and there's no going back.)
Kamilah Gill

I don't know. I find them suffocating, with the strict editorial/design scope simultaneously too explicit and too limiting. The focus on the LP specifically also dovetails with the Boomerish cultiness of the selected records. The Celine Dion book was interesting, since it did away with the worshipful, uncritical tone of much of the others. And the interior typesetting, as I recall, is frustratingly bad.

“Suffocating,” zbs? You’ve lost me there. They are longish texts for reading. The type is perfectly standard book text, nothing out of the ordinary: comfortable type size and readable line lengths. But it works. As for “Boomerish cultiness” — is this meant to write off an entire generation or two of listeners? And what’s wrong with a cult if by that you simply mean a group of listeners who share a strong taste? Sounds good to me. In fact, the series represents many kinds of popular music: Abba’s Abba Gold, Slayer’s Reign in Blood, Sly and the Family Stone’s There’s a Riot Goin’ On, P.J. Harvey’s Rid of Me, DJ Shadow’s Endtroducing..... and, yes, Celine Dion. Not my taste, but now I look into it, the Dion book sounds fascinating, so thanks for mentioning it, Kamilah.

While no one is going to spend months writing a book like this without feeling highly engaged by the subject, that doesn’t mean the books have to be hagiographic. Inevitably, the titles vary in critical ambition and quality of writing and, for me, as I’ve hinted, the series is over-reliant on American writers for British subjects. But there are some truly inspired pairings of writer and album: Mark Polizzotti, author of a biography of André Breton, on Dylan’s Highway 61 Revisited; Erik Davis, author of Techgnosis, on Led Zeppelin IV; and former Bookforum editor Andrew Hultkrans on Forever Changes.

Thanks for the kind words, Adam. I hope this suggests a few more to check out.
Rick Poynor

my friend and former colleague scott tennent wrote the volume in this series on the band slint. before he wrote this book, i had never heard to the band slint, and as i read it, i found that i had heard of none of the other bands or touchstones in the book, or at least few of them. i nevertheless enjoyed it a great deal. it was like reading a fictional account of some alternate universe that i never knew existed.
Mark Lamster

I want to put in a word for the Celine Dion book, it is really interesting even if you find her atrocious. And the MC5 book is probably "boomers only" but some cultural moments are simply too sublime and fleeting....
Lorraine Wild

Thanks, Lorraine. Three positive mentions now for the Celine Dion book. This I would never have predicted. I'm convinced.

Also intrigued by Mark's mention of the volume about Slint's Spiderland, which I haven't heard. It's one of the more recent volumes, published last year. The blurb describes the album as "the foundation for post rock in the 1990s." Interesting that the author now works as a writer and editor at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art. The series' willingness to draw on cultural perspectives from outside the music press is one of its strengths.
Rick Poynor

Jobs | July 15